Alaska Bill Would Bar Transgender Girls From Female Sports

A bill introduced in the waning days of this year's legislative session in Alaska would require schools to designate school-sponsored athletic teams or sports as male, female, or co-ed and require participation in a female sport to be based on the participant's sex assigned at birth.

The bill from Senate Majority Leader Shelley Hughes is the latest of its kind around the country that would bar transgender girls and women from girls and women's sports. Hughes, a Palmer Republican, in a statement Thursday said the bill is "the culmination of several months work" but indicated it would not be pushed during the final days of this session, scheduled to end next week.

"Currently, the Legislature is focusing efforts on pressing and time sensitive matters. That, and the fact that many committees have already begun ending their work this legislative session, means that my staff and I will be working over the interim on our plan to start the bill hearing process during the next legislative session," Hughes said. Bills pending in the current regular session carry over to next year.

Laura Carpenter, executive director of Identity, an Anchorage-based advocacy group for the lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender community, said the bill is discriminatory and "horrific."

"This is not about fairness in women’s sports," Carpenter said. "This is an anti-transgender bill that does not value trans lives."

The president of the conservative Alaska Family Council, Jim Minnery, urged support for the bill, calling it a way to ensure that "basic fairness and opportunities for women aren’t sidelined by the demands of radical gender ideologues."

Hughes spoke about the issue on the Senate floor last month, when she proposed, but withdrew, an amendment to a pandemic emergency bill that dealt with transgender athletes.

She said she wanted to use that "bully pulpit" to draw attention to an issue that she said she has had "more communication on" this year than the annual check Alaskans receive from the state's oil-wealth fund, a perennial hot-button.

"Alaskans want Alaskans' values, American values to be sustained," she said, noting later her plans to introduce a bill.

The bill, introduced Wednesday, states that public schools or private schools that have teams that compete against public schools must designate school-sponsored athletic teams or sports as a male, men or boys team or sport; a female, women or girls team or sport; or a co-ed team or sport.

It states that a student who participates in a team or sport designated for females, women or girls "must be female, based on the participant's biological sex."

Michael Garvey, advocacy director for the American Civil Liberties Union of Alaska, said his group opposes the bill. He said it raises privacy and other concerns and "singles out students who are transgender for discrimination."

A federal appeals court earlier this month heard arguments in a case involving an Idaho law that prohibits transgender students who identify as female from playing on female teams sponsored by public schools, colleges and universities. The law does not apply to men’s teams.