Lyft Inc. received some badly needed support on Tuesday, as analysts at banks that had worked on its initial public offering urged clients to buy the ride-hailing company’s beleaguered shares.
Following the required 25-day wait for deal underwriters to issue an investment opinion following an IPO, at least 10 of the banks that brought Lyft public gave positive recommendations on a stock that has slumped 30 percent from its opening price on March 29, its first day of trading.
KeyBank appeared to be the only bank launching coverage on Tuesday that did not recommend buying Lyft, instead assigning it a “sector weight” rating and warning of slowing growth.
As of Tuesday, 14 out of 22 analysts covering Lyft recommended buying the stock, seven were “neutral” and one recommended selling.
Lyft’s stock slump since its IPO has raised concerns about the valuation of larger rival Uber Technologies Inc as it prepares to promote its own long-anticipated public listing, expected next month.
Both companies have warned they may never become profitable, making it difficult for investors to estimate how much they might be worth.
“Uber’s filing has added pressure, and we acknowledge that the upcoming roadshow could create more near-term uncertainty, but we believe Lyft continues to execute well,” JPMorgan analyst Doug Anmuth wrote in his research report, assigning Lyft a $82 price target. The stock was trading Tuesday afternoon at $60.79.
Before Tuesday, only banks that had not worked on Lyft’s IPO were permitted to offer recommendations on the stock, and the balance of opinion in that group was decidedly more skeptical. Just four of them had recommended Lyft’s shares, while six initiated the stock as a “hold” and one as a “sell.”
Despite regulations that separate investment banking and research operations, it is rare for analysts at banks that have participated in an IPO to recommend selling that stock when they issue their initial opinions.
Even after Tuesday’s “buy” ratings, Shares of Lyft (LYFT) dipped 0.5%.
Due to its lack of profitability and dual class share structure guaranteeing insiders control of the company, Lyft is not eligible to be included in the benchmark S&P 500 stock index. But if it were, its poor average analyst rating would rank it in the bottom 10% of the benchmark index, among companies including Kraft Heinz Co and Gap Inc, according to Refinitiv data.
“We expect steady deceleration in market growth and Lyft’s pace of share gain, which seems likely to prevent revenue and adjusted EBITDA from meaningfully exceeding our expectations,” KeyBank analyst Andy Hargreaves.
Piper Jaffray expected “solid near-term top line results,” saying Lyft had been gaining market share in recent quarters, but that the path to positive net income would be a “multi-year journey.” It initiated coverage with an overweight rating and target price of $78.
Most of the analysts were confident of Lyft’s long-term fortunes, despite the competition from Uber.
Reuters has reported that Uber plans to sell around $10 billion worth of stock at a valuation of between $90 billion and $100 billion. Its IPO is on track for some time in May.
Lyft has a stock market value of around $17 billion.
At least six of Lyft’s underwriters, including Canaccord, Cowen and JMP Securities, are also backing the Uber deal, according to SEC filings.
© 2024 Thomson/Reuters. All rights reserved.